Duct tape holds the linoleum to the floor of the El Cerrito Library, and only two of its windows open. One of them can only be opened from the inside and closed from the outside. Behind the building, staff keep sandbags on the slope because the drainage can't keep up, and sand from them has spread across the concrete by the back door. Richmond Confidential reported those details from a public tour in October. They describe the 77-year-old building at 6510 Stockton Avenue, the city's only library, where one public room holds nearly everything.
For about two decades, the library conversation in El Cerrito was about money and land. Since the June 2 election it has been about this building. A city task force is now deciding whether to repair the existing structure or replace it. A repair would leave less usable room on a main floor that is already too small for programs the county runs at other branches.
Two Votes, and a Third Option That Never Came to a Ballot
The case for more space is older than most of the people now arguing about it. A 2014 City Council agenda report traces the first library needs assessment to 2005. That study recommended a facility of roughly 21,000 square feet, and a state construction bond the city had hoped to tap failed in 2006. City Manager Karen Pinkos told Richmond Confidential she has worked on financing a new or updated library for 25 years. "There's been so many different evolutions, what we've tried to do, and different land we've tried to buy," she said.
Voters have now been asked twice. In November 2016, Measure B would have authorized a $30 million loan for a new building, and it finished 4 percentage points short of the two-thirds majority it needed. In June 2026, Measure C was a citizen-led parcel tax of up to 17 cents per square foot of building area, collected each year for 30 years after construction bonds were issued. In the unofficial count Local News Matters reported on June 15, it lost 7,431 to 3,235, or 69.7 percent to 30.3 percent.
The third option sat in the background of both campaigns. The master plan for the housing now going up at El Cerrito Plaza BART covers 743 homes and lists a potential 20,000-square-foot public library. It also includes a 22,000-square-foot public plaza and a 145-space BART garage. The city estimated a library in that development at about $37.2 million, the cost Measure C would have covered. Construction at the station is moving without it. The first phase, 70 affordable apartments on Parcel A South built by Related California with Pyatok as architect and Nibbi Brothers as general contractor, broke ground in early March and is scheduled for completion in the first quarter of 2027.
Both Campaigns Said They Wanted a Library
The June result counted votes on one funding plan. It did not measure support for a library. The opposition, led by residents Barbara Chan and Wally Nowinski, campaigned under the line "libraries are good, the library tax is not," according to Local News Matters. Nowinski told the outlet his side's approach was to "talk to our neighbors and see what they think." As Richmond Confidential summarized it, opponents objected to paying a tax before the city had a building plan or a definite location.
Former Mayor Greg Lyman, who brought the funding plan to the City Council in 2025, took the opponents at their word. "They said they were in support of a library, just not this measure, so we will await them stepping forward with their proposal," he told Local News Matters.
So after June, both sides agreed on the goal and disagreed on how to pay for it. The building on Stockton Avenue still needed work no matter how the vote went. "Whether the ballot measure passes or fails is irrelevant. As you saw, this building needs work," Pinkos said during the October tour, as reported by Richmond Confidential.
The Task Force Is Weighing a Repair That Costs Floor Space
The city's Library Task Force was founded in February and held its first meeting on September 8. The City Manager's October update describes it as a seven-member group reviewing options and charged with bringing recommendations to the City Council on a new or updated library. Its October meeting was the public walk-through of the building on October 13. Its November 10 agenda, according to Richmond Confidential, was to estimate repair costs and review public records of past building inspections.
The building has been renovated only once, in 1960, and does not meet current seismic or accessibility standards. Bringing it up to code means widening the aisles between shelves and desks, and a contractor estimated that this alone could cut usable main-floor space by 10 to 15 percent. That main floor is one public room holding the shelves, the computer lab, and a children's section that also has to work as the event space.
Contra Costa County Librarian Alison McKee made the same point from the programming side during the tour. The county hasn't been able to bring the community wellness and tech-support events it runs at other branches to El Cerrito. "We just can't offer these services here because there's just no space for them," she said, according to Richmond Confidential. A repaired building would be safer and easier to get around, and it would also be smaller than the one that already can't host those programs.
The building's age shows up in day-to-day operations too. It has no air conditioning and has closed midday several times in recent years because of unsafe indoor temperatures. The basement holds staff offices and the Friends of the El Cerrito Library bookseller, and it has a history of water coming in. A spring 2023 flood ruined books too waterlogged to sell or recycle. At the end of the tour, Richmond Confidential reported, task force members asked branch manager Heidi Goldstein what she would want from a renovation. "Windows would be really nice," she said. "Probably my own office would be nice."
The Branch Keeps a Full Schedule in the Meantime
Whatever the task force recommends, the Stockton Avenue branch is open 46 hours a week this season. The Contra Costa County Library lists it as open Tuesday through Thursday from 10 a.m. to 8 p.m. and Friday and Saturday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. It is closed Sunday and Monday. Those evening hours make it easy to pick up holds after work midweek.
The branch's own calendar covers the next few weeks.
- Storytime for children up to age 5 and their caregivers is on Friday, November 20, the day after this post goes up.
- "Tradition! A History of Kung Pao Kosher Comedy" is on Thursday, December 3.
- First Saturday Stay and Play is on Saturday, December 5.
Library event listings can change, so check the county's El Cerrito events page for times before you go.
The Friends of the El Cerrito Library keep a sales shelf inside the branch that is open whenever the library is, and their next large book sale is planned for spring. If you're clearing shelves over the holidays, their workroom is closed and not taking donations on Saturday, November 28, and Saturday, December 26, according to the Friends' site. Every book bought off that shelf funds a group that has been part of the library's planning since the 2013–14 needs assessment.
Where to Follow the Decision
The task force meets publicly, and its meetings appear on the City of El Cerrito calendar. The City Manager's monthly update is the shortest summary of where the group stands between meetings. The October tour was also open to the public, and a dozen task force members, city and county staff, and residents followed Goldstein out the back door to see the sandbagged slope for themselves, according to Richmond Confidential. The task force's recommendation goes to the City Council next.
What happens to a civic building like the one on Stockton Avenue shapes the blocks around it. If you'd like to talk about El Cerrito with an agent who pays attention to decisions like this one, Red Oak Realty is glad to help, and you can start with our El Cerrito neighborhood page. Work with a Seriously Local Agent.